After studying the Dominican University library website, I think it has some positive features and is definitely moving in the right direction, but it could probably benefit from some modifications. NCSU and Columbia College Chicago are both good examples of how libraries can have a professional, yet fun site.
Visual attractiveness: I found the NCSU site- http://www.lib.ncsu.edu/ -very visually attractive. Instead of having a bare background with just one or two colors, the site makes use of photos at the top, graphics in the middle of the page, and different colors to enhance visual interest. The photos of the library and students studying add a fun visual element, and the color-coded boxes below make it easy for the students to eyeball what they’re looking for.
Columbia College’s site- http://www.lib.colum.edu/ -is very basic, yet still visually attractive. Although the site contains a white background, the photo and different color headings still keep it visually attractive without being boring. I also prefer Columbia’s use of fonts—the headings are bigger than the rest of the text, while NCSU uses almost entirely the same font throughout.
Layout/Ease of Use: NCSU lays out its information very nicely—everything is categorized into boxes. Additionally, in the “Browse Subjects: box, clicking one of the links brings up a pop-up box. You can then click on whichever field you’re looking for and are taken directly to that area’s information on research help and resources.One thing I like about both NCSU and the Columbia College site is that they both have information divided into different color categories and maintain the same color throughout the categories’ pages. For example, on the Columbia page, “find books” is under a red heading. If you click the link for it, the following page still keeps the red heading and the research tab stays on the right side of the page. You always know what part of the site you’re at and it makes it easier to navigate. For example, see the link http://www.lib.colum.edu/research/findBooks.php
I once had a co-worker describe what he called the “toilet paper” site—the kind of site that just keeps scrolling and scrolling. NCSU and Columbia both manage to keep all of their information on one page and structured in a way that requires little scrolling.
Content/human element: As a primarily visual arts and media school, Columbia College does a good job of tailoring their site to their unique student body. The “About” section contains links to images from the library’s art exhibits, and the library blog (found under “Library News) uses language and topics familiar to arts students. For example, there’s an entry on a staff member who was named “one to watch” in fashion and links to his own clothing design line. This shows that the staff knows how to connect with their student body.
Suggestions for Dominican site improvements
Visual appearance: The current library website- http://domweb.dom.edu/library/crown/ -is a little stark and bland; it doesn’t attract much visual interest. I think Dominican could take a cue from NCSU and Columbia and add some color to the site, perhaps by color-coding the different categories.
Layout/ease of use: I like the categories and would not change them, but I would perhaps arrange them in a different way—it would help to not have to scroll down too much. Perhaps if they were arranged in columns of three rather than two, it would make the site easier to navigate. It would also help if separate categories were created for faculty/staff and students. The faculty link could include information such as how to book an instruction session, while the student link could include information such as how to how to view what’s checked out on their account.
There were also a few cases of clicking a link and having the subsequent page contain mostly white space at the top, forcing you to scroll down to view the information, such as when you follow this link http://domweb.dom.edu/library/crown/lib/govdocs.htm. The white space at the top should be eliminated.
Content/human element:The Dominican library site doesn’t feel very personal. When you access the library site from Dominican’s home page, you see the icon and quote of Michael Stephens, which I like, but it would also help to add a ‘welcome’ graphic and a photo or two—perhaps of students studying in the cyber café or at one of the tables.The Dominican library site has some helpful features and is off to a good start, but a little retouching will help make it even better!